en flag
nl flag
zh flag
fr flag
de flag
ja flag
ko flag
ru flag
es flag
Listen To Article

Monday night I finally got around to watching The Two Popes on Netflix. Directed by Fernando Mereilles, the film centers around Pope Benedict’s surprising resignation from the papacy in 2013, and Pope Francis’ unlikely ascendancy into the same role. It’s a marvelous film. The performances by Hopkins (Benedict) and Pryce (Francis) have earned them well-deserved Oscar nominations. The scenery is stunning, the camera angles surprising, the music choices delightfully quirky, and the pace – given that most of the movie is simply two old men talking to each other – is engaging.

As I watched, I thought back to an evening I spent in front of St. Peter’s Basilica, listening to Pope Benedict just two months before his resignation. At the end of December 2012, I joined 40,000 other young people from around the world for the Taizé European Meeting in Rome. This gathering takes place in a different European city every winter, a microcosm event of the week-long gatherings in the ecumenical community of Taizé, France.

40,000 people waiting for lunch at the Circus Maximus

I had been to Taizé the summer of 2011, an experience that was deeply formative. Every week thousands of young people gather from all over the world and every possible denomination, to pray together (using the simple refrains of Taizé music), eat together, and learn together. Morning prayers, including the Eucharist, begin at 8:15 – the first words you say are words of prayer, the first food you eat the communion loaf. After a breakfast of rolls and sticks of chocolate, folks break off into common-language groups to study one of the gospels, and then split into smaller groups for two hours of discussion. At 12:30 there’s midday prayers and lunch, followed by time spent in work groups. Dinner is followed by evening prayers, ending around 9:30, after which is free time until the bell tolls for silence at 11:30.

It was a boisterous, loud, chaotic, peaceful, emotional, and deeply ecumenical week.

Within hours of arrival I made friends with folks with whom I would remain close for years – especially Michael from Germany and Alicia from Poland, both Roman Catholics. Two years later we were reunited in Rome, recreating the routine of Taizé, but with prayers and activities spread throughout the city’s basilicas.

Prayers at Taize

On the second day of our gathering, we made our way to St. Peter’s Basilica Square and managed to get seats just 12 rows from the steps of the Basilica, from which the pope would address us. After three hours of waiting, the pope arrived in the popemobile, meandering through the rows and rows and rows of people, waving gently and smiling. He passed within ten feet of us, and for just a moment I made eye contact with him as he rode by. He might not be my pope, but he was still the pope, and that was still an exceptionally cool moment.

Alas, the popemobile doesn’t move quite slowly enough for one to both wave and get a good picture.

The service proceeded with singing, lighting candles, and a message from the Pope about unity. “You young people,” he said, “Orthodox, Protestant, Catholics…you are Jesus to the people on Earth.”


And indeed, what I loved about the week in Taizé and the week in Rome was worshipping with people who believe differently than I do and worship differently than I do, and yet at the core, are unified by our belief in Christ. Its one of the reasons I love the Calvin Worship Symposium, an event whose attendees represent thirty different countries and forty denominations. Its why I loved interning at the American Protestant Church of the Hague, a community of believers made up at any given time of expats from sixty different countries and forty denominations.

In that moment of worship, our unity is greater than the sum of our differences. We can experience something together, something shared, something binding, even if we vote differently, or speak a different language, or eat different foods.

In the midst of polarization, outrage, and animosity, we often talk about the need to learn to dialogue with each other. I wonder if first, or perhaps alongside this, we need to create more opportunities to worship together. To remember what it is that we, as Christians, have in common. Whether white or black, Republican or Democrat, Asian or European, gay or straight. To practice the unity that is greater than the sum of our differences. And maybe then we’ll have a starting point from which to build some bridges.

To close with another movie, one of my all-time favorite scenes is the final one in the 1984 drama Places in the Heart. The movie navigates the tense relationships between numerous characters in a small Texan town during the Great Depression. In the early scenes, Sheriff Royce Spalding is killed by a young black man named Wylie. Wylie is then beaten and lynched in revenge. The sheriff’s widow, Edna, must fight to keep her farm afloat as she cares for her two young children, and makes room for a blind man who comes to board with them. Eventually a black man named Moses comes to work on the farm and must reckon with the towns distrust and racism.

The final scene takes place in a church, during the celebration of Communion. The elements are passed down the row, from neighbor to neighbor, all these characters learning to live together. Finally, in a moment of surrealism, the camera comes to rest on Royce Spalding and Wylie. Royce passes the wine to Wylie, and as Wylie takes it, he murmurs, “The peace of God.”

Those are the final words of the film.

There is much work to be done to reconcile with each other, to seek justice, to repair damages, to find solutions together. But here, perhaps, is a place to begin – extending Jesus to each other, and maybe finding some peace.

Laura de Jong

Laura de Jong serves as pastor of Second Christian Reformed Church in Grand Haven, Michigan.

7 Comments

  • Daniel J Meeter says:

    You brought me along.

  • Scott Hoezee says:

    Thanks, Laura. And Places in the Heart is an all-time favorite. I have used that closing clip in presentations quite a few times. Incidentally, did you know that director Robert Benton placed such a high value on that kingdom-of-God-glimpse communion scene that he had a special camera dolly built just so the camera could follow the communion elements as they passed person to person. Maybe the most theologically rich moment ever captured on film. And you’re right: it brings tears because it is the vision of unity we all yearn for. Thanks!

  • Eric Van Dyken says:

    Laura, I like your writing. It seems to me that God has blessed you with a kind and gentle soul.

  • John Kleinheksel says:

    Thanks Laura.
    For a refreshing ecumenical worship experience, for those in W. MI, come worship at First United Meth. in Holland, 5:00 p.m. this Sunday, January 19. 65 of us will be in the choir. CRC, RCA, Methodist, Roman Catholics, Pentecostals, Presbyterians, Lutherans, African Americans. Colleague Bob Batastini (St. Francis de Sales) will direct the choir. To kick off the Week of Prayer for Christian Unity. Sponsored by CUSP (Christians United in Song and Praise).
    Google CUSP for more details. Singing and praising the One God might go a long way toward honoring our Lord’s Prayer that “they may be one, even and I am in you and you are in me” (John 17).

  • Gary VanHouten says:

    I haven’t seen The Two Popes, but did see this article entitled, “Two Popes at odds as Benedict attacks plans for married priests amid fears over ‘parallel papacy.” Read it here: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/01/13/popes-francis-benedict-clash-priestly-celibacy-row-underlines/
    Thanks for your piece, Laura. Always enjoy your perspective.

  • Daniel J Meeter says:

    There’s also a very moving Holy Communion scene in the 1982 Italian movie, Night of the Shooting Stars. It’s a fabulous movie all around.

Leave a Reply