Sorting by

Skip to main content

Nothing is Wasted

By November 14, 2015 6 Comments

“And speaking of things overheard, you heard right:
if I have to go out, I am going to go out singing.” – Brett Foster

I’d like to believe that when someone dies young, say from cancer at age 42, leaving a young family behind, I’d like to believe that “nothing is wasted.” That’s the sort of thing we say to each other: “Even though we don’t understand, his life was complete.” God called him home. Romans 8, etc. I’d like to believe all that.

We heard of Brett’s death on Tuesday. Friday morning, my first pass through my email revealed that a good colleague, June, is now in hospice. I had no idea the breast cancer had aggressed into bone cancer. A few hours later, another email brought the news that Brett’s colleague in the English department at Wheaton College, Roger Lundin, died Thursday, age 66. Two in one week for them. For all of us.

This is what happens to people we admire, to people we love.

Don’t tell me nothing is wasted. These too-young deaths, they fray the fabric of our delicate hope.


The third week of July on a day just after a rain, blueberry bushes are so laden, they look blue from a distance. We go out there with our plastic-lined buckets tied to our waists with a rope, and we stand by head-high bushes and pick. It’s easy. Our fingers roll the plump berries off the stems in bunches. The buckets fill quickly. In the straw beneath each bush are the berries that dropped, rotting on the ground. The bushes produce far more than the u-pickers will ever pick, far more than the rolling machines will shake into metal bins. Thousands of berries will drop on the ground and rot.

Oh, but nature never wastes. The dropped berries are broken down by microbes and they return to the soil and fertilize the bushes, or they pass through the digestive systems of birds and return nitrogen to the soil somewhere a mile away.

Nature depends on the principle of redundancy, even gross overabundance. Berries, cottonwood seeds, tadpoles, spermatozoa, sparrows, mosquitoes. A deer produces twin fawns. If one is weak, it will be abandoned. No matter. The other survives, and the weaker fawn feeds the wolf cubs. It’s the circle of life.

At least, that’s one way to look at it. The other is: Nature may abhor a vacuum, but it does not abhor waste. Nature revels in waste, glories in it, spins it into the swirling patterns of life.

Is that how God sees the patterns of our lives, like so many twin fawns? Some will live long, some will die young. They succumb to the wolves. No matter. It’s the circle of life.


“God is in the salvage business.” That’s another thing we say to each other, especially to salve over the ways we screw up our lives. I believe this one, but that doesn’t cancel out the possibility of waste. The man who now works the strip clubs in Baltimore’s red light district, arranging for health care and rehab for the dancers and bouncers who don’t trust anyone else—he spent twenty years as a heroin addict before getting clean and going to work helping others. Well, beautiful. God redeemed his life. True, he wouldn’t have street cred with the people he serves if not for his time on the streets selling drugs to support his habit. But don’t tell me those twenty years weren’t wasted. “I was a predator to my community”—that’s how he sums up those years. I bet he wishes he could have spent twenty years learning to play the saxophone instead.

And what about this man’s son, shot dead amid the violence in Baltimore last spring? The loss of that young man’s future: what a waste. What about the people who died in the church in Charleston, what about all the black lives who matter but are cut short in snarls of hate? Or all the children who have died—so far—in this country’s scourge of gun violence in schools, the soldiers killed in mistaken wars, the innocents killed by bombs or machine guns, randomly, senselessly?

What about the hundreds of people killed or injured in yet another terror attack yesterday in Paris? Was that not a waste?

And what about lives diminished and talents lost when people suffer from chronic illness, or languish in prison, or succumb to crippling depression? The faces, the losses crowd my imagination. It’s too much! Waste waste waste.

Don’t tell me it’s not a waste.


It’s not that lives diminished or cut short are not meaningful, valuable, purposeful, beautiful. Brett blessed many people, and he leaves behind a legacy in his family, his students, his friends, his writing, his work. So did my friend Karen and my colleague Bill. There’s a way to cherish something precious for every name on our personal lists. It’s tempting, in fact, to regard a life as more precious when it is somehow limited or cut short.

But the missing futures, the lost possibilities. That’s what makes me angry.

That’s why I lament.

Potential gone to waste. It could have been different. Why isn’t it different? Is all-that-could-have-been held in the mind of God? Is that enough?

God salvages, yes. But what could have been. That’s what leadens my heart.

Does God revel in waste, glory in it, spin it into the swirling patterns of life?

“See I have engraved you on the palms of my hands.” – Is. 49:16


Here is the full poem by Brett Foster from which the epigraph is taken.

Debra Rienstra

I am a writer and literature professor, teaching literature and creative writing at Calvin University, where I have been on the faculty since 1996. Born and bred in the Reformed tradition, I’ve been unable to resist writing four books about theological topics: beware the writer doing theology without a license. My most recent book is Refugia Faith: Seeking Hidden Shelters, Ordinary Wonders, and the Healing of the Earth (Fortress, 2022). Besides the books, I’ve written well over two hundred essays for the RJ blog as well as numerous articles, poems, and reviews in popular and scholarly contexts. I have a B.A. from the University of Michigan (Go Blue!) and a M.A. and Ph.D. from Rutgers. I am married to Rev. Dr. Ron Rienstra, and together we have three grown children. Besides reading and writing, I love classical music, science fiction, fussing in the yard, hiking, and teaching myself useful skills like plant identification and—maybe someday—drywall repair.


  • Monica says:

    Wow. Thank you for writing this. Such raw, honest, eloquent feeling.

  • Lee Collins says:

    Waste, indeed. How can one make any sense of such tragedy as Paris? Or dying young? Or floods or hurricanes?

    Faith is challenged by such events.

  • Henry Baron says:

    You gave utterance to my heart’s feelings, Debra – thank you!

  • Jan Heerspink says:

    Thank you, Debra. Your words give voice to my thoughts. I visited with dear June yesterday, along with some other Calvin colleagues. It’s too hard.

  • Margaret says:

    Thank-you Debra, I appreciate you sharing your thoughts.
    these are complicated struggles and difficult to verbalize.

    I wish that the dreadful years of my childhood had never happened. I wish that healing had come much sooner and that I had not hurt other people.
    – if this had not been done to me -if I had not gone through this journey,
    I would not know God as I know Him now.
    My suffering
    -the suffering of others
    -is not a waste!
    I do not understand all the reasons why God allows what He allows.
    As you wrote, I too would like to have learned many things, including how to carve stone and to earn a teaching degree.
    I would really like to have learned to properly love people, much sooner.
    Yet here I am, no way to be other than what I am at the stage I am, no chance to grow up as whatever normal is. . .
    God is not wasting this.
    I see Him this way because of it all.
    He is Thee glorious, awesome,Master of the universe and deliberately, intricately, lovingly, intensely interested in His relationship with me. I revel in this.
    I see my Beautiful Jesus and the Gift He has given me. How He gave Himself and suffered so that He could enter in to my suffering and I could understand His a tiny bit.
    I have watched Him change my entire way of living/being.
    I know the many joys of my life with Him, the deep peace of forgiveness (both receiving and giving), serving with Him in His work on earth, and the gift of loving, listening, praying with others like me.
    The best thing for all of us is to be deeply entwined in God and what He does and Who He is.
    Suffering or intentionally sharing in the suffering of others is a path to this.

Leave a Reply