On Sunday afternoon, I led my last worship service as an ordained Minister of the Word in the Christian Reformed Church in North America. The service wasn’t in a Christian Reformed church – it was in the auditorium of the long term care home where I am the pastor. Before the service, I set a vase of six roses on the table at the front of the room – funeral roses given to me by the daughter of a resident I’d buried a couple of days prior.
I passed out the songbooks to the gathering residents, greeting them by name and making sure the books were turned to the page of our first song. I played a prelude on the digital piano – an arrangement of His Eye is on the Sparrow. One of the residents sang along.
I led the service based on the conclusion of the Lord’s Prayer, including a communal reciting of Question and Answer 128 of the Heidelberg Catechism. (The service is ecumenical, and the residents are from all sorts of traditions, but they’re fine with me bringing my reformed self to the work of worship!) “We have made all these petitions of you,” Answer 128 prays, “because as our all-powerful king, you are both willing and able to give us all that is good.”
At the end of the service, I told them they were about to receive a blessing that would be special to me. I didn’t get into all the details, but I told them that I had been ordained 19 years ago as a Minister of the Word in my denomination and that I was going to be released from that ordination later in the week. I assured them that I could still be their pastor, but that I wouldn’t be serving them communion, wearing my collar, or raising my hands to bless them for a while. “Eventually I’ll be ordained in a different denomination,” I said. “But this blessing is special to me because it will be the last one I give in an important chapter of my life.”
I raised my hands and felt the familiar energy of that holy moment rush through me – not only to the ends of my fingers this time, but also to my eyes, which filled with startling tears. The words of Numbers 6 were heavy and sweet in my mouth as I caught the eyes of as many residents as I could. “The Lord bless you and keep you. The Lord make his face to shine on you and be gracious to you. The Lord turn his face toward you and give you his peace. Amen.”
Mirror neurons fired and some of the residents reflected my tears. We sang Abide With Me. I played a short postlude and then brought the roses around to each resident. Some of them cannot see or hear very well, but most could touch or smell the orange, red, yellow, and white blooms.
Two days later on a windy afternoon in Cobourg, Ontario, I was honorably released from the office of Minister of the Word in the Christian Reformed Church. Though I look forward to a future ordination in the Reformed Church of America, I do not plan to rush into it. I want to experience the un-reverending and welcome the emotions, thoughts, and callings that come in the wake of it.
I will lean into the release – the sorrow of it, but also the freedom of it.
The penultimate chapter of Marilyn McEntyre’s book, Word by Word: A Daily Spiritual Practice, is accompanying me this week. Each day in this week of my reading, she explores an aspect of the word ‘leave.’ “How apropos,” I thought as I scanned the themes of the days:
Leave…
- yesterday behind
- what fosters no love
- what has served its purpose
- when it’s time to rest
My ordination in the Christian Reformed Church has served its purpose. And now I leave it behind and join Marilyn in her daily reflection: “Part of my morning prayer,” she writes, “is that I be kept aware of and attentive to my deepest purposes, which reveal themselves in God’s good time. Yesterday’s manna is no longer fit to eat. And if I want a share of today’s good wine, I’ll need to be ready with new wineskins” (200).
Indeed.
I sing because I’m happy. I sing because I’m free!
For his eye is on the sparrow, and I know he watches me.
Heidi I don’t know you but have always enjoyed your posts in RJ. Blessings to you on whatever your future holds. Sadly, wonderful people like you will continue to leave the CRC. What a mess Synod 2024 has made of the church.
Thank you, Kris. First comes the dying, then comes the rising.
All grace and peace, all blessings be upon you, Heidi! I know that you will be held. Wait on the Lord, and be of good courage. Your leave-taking gives me hope.
Blessing you with love, Jenny. May our virtual spaces continue to cross – and someday, perhaps our non-virtual space!
Dear Heidi
My eyes welled up a d my heart is heavy. You have taught me so much over the years and hopefully will continue to. Your grace and courage are a testament to your faith and convictions. May the Lord bless you and keep you as well, Heidi! Thank you for your words on leaving. Much love, Winnie.
‘the sorrow but also the freedom’ — your words overflow my heart at so many levels. I know the Lord is filling you with His peace. 💗🙏😔
Thank you for letting your mirror neurons fire, Winnie, and for letting your heart overflow, Laura. We will continue in our collaborations for the kingdom!
I’m so very sorry, Heidi. My heart hurts with you and I welcome you with open arms to the RCA when that time feels right for you.
– Sara
Thank you, Sara. I look forward to getting to know my new denomination in due time.
Love you so much, Heidi. God continues to work through you, no matter the denomination. He’s far bigger than any single denomination’s view. I love how he keeps guiding you into various ways to serve, including your writing, which is so vulnerable and beautifully done. Keep your eyes on him, the source of all truth 🩷🩷
Indeed. God is bigger. And God’s love and truth are bigger than any of us can imagine. Love you, Aunt Paula!
oh, dear Heidi. I’m so very deeply saddened at this, even though I sense you are probably in better space than I am about such things. I’m saddened, furious, and could write some other things that would get me blocked/blanked, so I’ll leave it there.
The very tool used to clobber people in the CRCNA is one you have turned around so very well–using the Heidelberg as intended. Thanks for the pastoral care in this story and in sharing it with us.
The anger has its place. I have welcomed it and used it as the fuel I have needed to be courageous. Thank you for naming the Mad alongside the Sad. All Parts Welcome!
Thanks for the blessing that I received as I pictured you blessing those people in the long term care home. Remember that you don’t have to be ordained to bless others. God’s mission is to bless the nations. The Church’s mission is be blessed and a blessing. Receive and give away, receive and give away, receive and give away. Blessed and a blessing. I’m filing a copy of your blog in my journal for future ripples …
Bill
Oh, yes, Bill. The blessing continues. I am part of the priesthood of all believers, after all! Glad to be in that priesthood with you, friend. And to receive your blessing, even as you receive mine.
Oh Heidi, I remember well the joy of your ordination on that September Sunday, and your wonderful service as pastor for discernment at the seminary. I remember too your installation in your second church and the joy, each time, of receiving God’s blessing through you. I know that God will continue to bless and keep you, and give you peace. And God will do that for all the sparrows that will sing because they’re free. “If the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.”
This comment was a lush chord of memory, Kathy. Thank you for traveling with me all of this years!
Heidi. All the hugs. All the love. The Spirit has so powerfully gifted you and called you. May you find delight and restorative rest in this sabbath between places….
Yes, Amanda! The liminal Sabbath time. So very good. You have known me for so long and it is always a delight to intersect with you in our thoughts about God and love and the world.
Heidi, I only know you through your writing, and through some ancient friends of ours in a book club who so appreciated you as their pastor. I’m also in process of leaving, but in emeritus status and with little practical effect, but sad nevertheless. Bless you for your integrity, for making lemonaide out of lemons, and for being a blessing wherever you serve.
We do have some sweet overlapping circles, dear Al! I am so grateful for you and your witness… Your solidarity with other allies has great practical effect! We’ll see what God gives for your next chapter, and for mine.
Thanks Heidi – I still remember your meditation years ago at synod on ‘back stories’, and how they form us. I, too, am leaving, but am grateful for the back story I have in the CRC – it has formed my faith and that of my family. I’m trusting that our back stories have prepared us for our future stories. And even though we don’t know for sure what that will look like here on earth, we know where it ultimately leads us. God bless you on your journey of faith and faithful service to the kingdom.
Thank you, Diane. Yes, we can remember our back stories with love and gratitude, even as we we walk into our front stories… all of them converging in the kingdom of everlasting light.
What the CRCNA provided you with will be welcomed with open arms in whatever church you choose next. Our friends and the leadership of the United Methodist Church gratefully accept our CRC past, thankful that we come deeply committed and leadership ready to serve our Lord in a denomination that we thought was “second-best”. How wrong we were. We felt every word you typed, but you are well on your way to your next calling. We are praying with you, Heidi.
Thank you, Gary and Mary! We are worshiping in a Free Methodist congregation, presently, and finding deep joy there. So grateful for the places where the lost can be found.
The reality of what happened at Synod 2024 hit home like a ton of bricks with the reading of this blog. The emotions of sadness and disappointment finally gave way to a flood of tears as I read your blog, Heidi.
Wishing you peace and joy in your new found freedom.
Oh, the cleansing flood of tears. I pray this was a good release for you and grateful that my words and the Spirit could open those gates. The interior and exterior freedom is certainly both peaceful and joyous.
Heidi, Ron and I talked this morning about the joy we felt for you as we watched your ordination in the CRC. Your gifts enriched the CRC. Wherever you go and whatever you do lives will continue to be enriched and led in faith by your words and your presence.
We also have felt the sadness of leaving and the freedom and joy of finding love and faith in another denomination. It was a lesson for us to learn that love and faith are not exclusive to one denomination. Praying the peace may accompany your journey.
Thank you, dear Pat. I remember you and Ron with gratitude as I reflect on our overlap at Faith CRC. We had some good manna together there! I am glad you have found a new denominational place to bloom and grow!
Heidi,
Thanks for this beautiful, sad reflection. Those people were blessed to be there, as are we to read it here.
And thanks for “Abide With Me,” a song I still cherish with a word that has a lot to do with “tolerance.”
… through cloud and sunshine…
… heaven’s morning breaks…
Thanks, Mark – grateful you are a part of the cloud of witnesses.
Heidi, This was hard to read. No matter the denomination, I’m sure our Lord is saying,” Well done, Heidi, good and faithful servant.”
Thank you, Glenda. Appropriate words for us as we cross the border from one vocation to the next… from one life to the next…
Dear Heidi,
I remember you well from my years on the CTS BOT when you were a student at the Seminary. I thank our Lord for your faithful service to his church these past nineteen years. The CRCNA is being diminished by your departure, as well as by the forced departure of other wonderful pastors like you. These past few years have been a nightmare for me, too, and I grieve for the denomination that has been my home for almost 90 years.
Go in peace,
Jack
Oh, Jack. Thank you for your faithful service to and participation in the denomination of our births. Remembering those years at CTS with love and gratitude.
The strange balance between sorrow and hope in this moment is reflected clearly in your piece. I weep with you in your sorrow and pray with you in hope.
Blessings to you wherever you are led to serve.
Thank you, Jen! Sorrow and Hope… and the dance between. Blessings on you.
So beautifully written, so beautifully lived out in your life where ever you serve. Thank you for putting into word what your soul inhabits.
YES, Barb. So good. The integrity and matching of the habitation of my soul and the articulation of my words is so important to me. The lack of that matching is disintegrating for me. Thankful for the freedom that comes from the consistency between thought and word (or deed).
Oh my heart breaks all over again and is freed by your words Heidi. Thank you for expressing so beautifully how many of us feel who have been released honorably from ministry in the crc but who still mourn the injustice of it all as well as anticipate God’s goodness each day and in the future. Much love to you and your family as you enter into this new season and continue to minister to those around you. May you find the grace through it all to remember to minister to yourself now too.
Thank you for this blessing – reminding me to be gentle with myself. May we rest and work in the freedom that is ours.
Am I the only one who wonders what a strange view of ministry and ordination the CRCNA must be laboring under for this story to be even imagined!!
Strange views… strange fruits… And you get at the crux of it all… what do we even mean by these words – our mental models of these designations (and our mental models of words like ‘truth,’ and ‘love,’ and ‘welcome,’ and ‘unchastity’) clash and crash as we labor on…
Thank you for these words Heidi. I really appreciated the training I received through you ate the CRC Burlington office addressing restorative practices in congregations (ironic – if only the CRCNA could practice such restoration. You are leaving a human made institution, a denomination that has publicly aired its fallibility; I am grateful that you can still minister in faith. CRCNA just lost another excellent pastor. Courage in the journey!
Thank you, Pat. It was a privilege to teach and learn alongside you last year. I continue to hold Restorative Practices with so much gratitude – as they have been a key that unlocks my heart in the midst of fear and conflict. May we all live as restoratively as we can in the institutions and organizations and communities we inhabit!
Heidi, This is beautiful and hard. I’m grateful for you and your witness. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
You’re welcome, dear Dana. So glad we’ve now finally met so that we can picture each other in living colour as we read each other’s work!
Heidi, I still remember the four of us having coffee as Rick was discerning a call. Your life and passion for others has always stuck with me. Praying for you as you leave one chapter and move to another. Rick & I have not regretted our decision to move over to the RCA. We still encounter those with viewpoints that are completely opposite of ours but God leads us through these difficult waters. May God continue to give you His rest and peace. I look forward to seeing how and where God uses you next.
Yes, Rose! We have been swimming in similar waters for so many years! And you make an important point, we can thrive in contexts of deep disagreement, provided that the disagreement is expected, welcomed, and given a larger crucible…
Peace and blessings as you go forward!
Thank you, Mary.
Don’t go away, Heidi – as your readers here who have been blessed by your presence we look forward to more of it in our disaffiliated future.
I am not going anywhere when it comes to the RJ! Still a Christian. Still Reformed. Still part of the church. Still writing!
Hello Heidi, please add me to the list of so many people who have deeply appreciated your care as a pastor. We will always be thankful for that. These are the days of lament, at least for a while as we witness the fracturing of the CRC). I thought it tragic that there was so little lament at synod 2024 . Your swan song here brings that lament to the front burner where it should be. Thank you for helping us be sad. Such a tragedy right before our eyes. All of us who have deeply loved and have lost the CRC will wish you well!
Dear Ron, thank you for being a companion in the journey. Your professorship is a deep well of learning for me. I return to it over and over again with gratitude. And thank you for adding your voice to the communal lament.
Just excellent, Heidi. The words of Numbers 6 were heavy and sweet, and blessing going out through your fingertips. Giving wonderful words to my own feelings in leading worship. You write this as sort of a Nunc Dimittis, the Song of Simeon. When, years ago, for our little Hungarian church, Melody set the Nunc Dimittis for the Genevan metre, she made this out of the first line: “Now Master let me go, let now your servant go.”
Oh, I would love to hear Melody’s Nunc Dimittis! And YES – this is a strong and sharp juxtaposition… setting Simeon’s song next to my departing. Thank you.
Not too many words now. Many, many prayers.
Wordless groans of the spirit. Thank you.
You will flourish without the encumbrances of the CRCNA. Thank you for listening to and following the Spirit. She has much more for you to do.
Yes, she does. Thank you, Thomas.
God bless you in this transition time. Thank you for making the decision to turn toward love. There’s still “angles” on your shoulders.
Pat Weatherwax, CPE 2004
Yes, leaving what fosters no love. Ah, 20 years ago…. Thank you for the memory.
Dear Heidi,
Among your many gifts are wisdom, compassion, honesty, and courage. We took different paths in our seminary years and subsequent occupations, but the witness of your obedience to your calling shaped me and blessed me in ways I’m only realizing now. Thank you. From the comments here, it’s clear your gifts have shaped and blessed many. The Spirit who shines a light that we might see more—and love more!—shines through you, my friend.
Becca – I’m so glad our winding paths have gotten closer these last couple of years in the context of our love for the written word. Thank you for holding space for me and allowing me to hold space for you.
Heidi- I grieve this loss and transition with you, even as I welcome you into the fold of the RCA. Thank you for sharing this honest and vulnerable reflection. I’m so sorry the church has done this to you.
Thank you, Cameron. The pain for me is so small compared to that of my queer fellow-humans. But there is pain – in being misrepresented, misunderstood, mischaracterized. Thank you for naming this as something ‘done to’ me.
Heidi, as one who loves the power of words, thank you for sharing yours here. My heart is both happy and heavy with you. Blessings as you continue to minister to your senior saints.
Thanks, friend. I LOVE my senior saints so very much. Will keep on loving them… and my saints in their teens and twenties at Queen’s. Such a holy span!
Thank you for sharing yourself, your grief, and your love.
You are welcome, Mara. Thank you for naming these things. Reminds me of a bit from Chuck’s new book I read the other day… that what people what from us is ourSELVES, rather than ourSOLVES. That is the way I write.
The walk through this time of transition will be a gift. I pray you will know the embrace of the Spirit as things come apart, as pieces scatter, as you rest amidst change, as you contemplate your next step, as you prepare for God’s future and mostly, as you examine the scattered pieces and discern which to let be, which to re-assemble and put on a shelf and which to take with you.
Thank you so much for this Paul. Reminds me of Our World Belongs to God: “We marvel that the Lord gathers the broken pieces to do his work.” And yes, some are meant to be gathered… some to be left behind…
Heidi,
Please continue to serve the Lord’s Supper at the care facility, and raise your hands in blessing.
Ordination is for a life time. Credentials may be temporary, but loss of credentials does not cancel
ordination. We can continue to do those rituals which distribute God’s grace and love.
Jim Stoel
Hello, Jim… Thank you for this invitation. I can see how that might have been a way that I would have moved forward with integrity, but I will be putting these official acts of ministry on pause – at least for a time – in order to lean into the loss.
Thank you for this, Heidi. I so appreciate your trust that you are being called away in order to be called toward, and your willingness to take that process slowly, sitting with the pain that comes with such a transition. Thank you also for the mention of my words; I’m so grateful they were able to meet you at the right moment. We never know. Your own words are helpful to me in my own restlessness. Blessings and peace to you as you continue.
Thank you, Marilyn – for the way you’ve walked with me – word by word – without even knowing it. Your words (which are the balm of You and the Spirit) have been so anchoring. The final chapter in that book – WELCOME – is just what I needed for this week. Of course.
Just got to read this, Heidi, after a fraught week–not a little of which comes from my own lack of progress on discerning what God might have next for this retired CRC pastor. I was happy you said “mad and sad” above, b/c until a friend who knows me too well said, “I know you well enough to recognize that you are hiding, maybe denying your sadness with your anger.” He was so right. The grieving is really hard, but your grace-filled words help nudge me ever closer to that fitting sadness and, I pray, shed some light on the clouds surrounding my discernment. 20 years–not quite half of my 47 years. But 20 years filled with grace and candour and deep empathy. Blessings and thanks again and again. jcd
Just seeing this and reading this for the first time now, Heidi. I am grateful for this and grateful for you–your experiences, your willingness to give those experiences voice in such candid and remarkably beautiful ways, and your friendship even from a distance of both time and place. May God continue to bless your work.