Essay

Remembrance

By April 26, 2019 6 Comments
Listen To Article

The only means of getting man and woman, beast and wagon across the rain-swollen Niobrara River was by rope, hand over hand. Dozens of oxen and as many as 500 horses had to get to the other side, as did 523 Ponca men, women, and children.

And the rain wouldn’t stop. All those wagons were disassembled and shouldered through and over the raging river. It took a day to recover, yet another rainy day.

In May of 1877, after endless haggling and heartless bureaucratic inertia, someone in faraway Washington determined that the Poncas of  Nebraska would be forced to leave their villages, their homes and schools and churches, their sawmill, their flour mill and everything they owned, and walk to Oklahoma–Indian Territory.

Imagine 500 people in soggy early May trudging up and down endless muddy hills along the Missouri. Imagine never-ending rains that made some days impossible to travel. 

Try to imagine you and your family walking, north to south, the entire state of Nebraska, then all of Kansas, only to reach a place your elders already determined so “stony and broken” they could never live there and would never love. Imagine endless rainy days and nights, forever cold and clammy. No rest for the weary. No shelter in the time of storm.

And you didn’t want to go. You just plain hated the idea of leaving the place your people had lived for generations. That last night in the village, no one slept. There was too much crying.

Is it any wonder people took sick? Is it any wonder some of the most vulnerable would die? Should we be surprised that the Ponca’s Trail of Tears has countless unmarked graves? 

Truth be told, the Ponca never made life troublesome for anyone. They hadn’t attacked wagon trains or stolen horses, were never belligerent. From the Poncas, Washington had little to fear. But the government determined the Ponca had to leave for Indian Territory because they were Indian.

On May 23, not far from the Elkhorn River and near a tiny frontier town named Neligh, the little daughter of Black Elk and Moon Hawk, succumbed to pneumonia. White Buffalo Girl was all of 18 months. 

Her parents had watched her die and were frantic, beyond grief. A Neligh carpenter nailed together a wooden cross. Her family was Christian. 

Up above town in a cemetery called Laurel Hill, her father, distraught, talked to white folks who, with the Ponca, had gathered around that wooden cross.

“I want the whites to respect the grave of my child just as they do the graves of their own dead,” Black Elk said. “The Indians do not like to leave the graves of their ancestors, but we had to move and hope it will be for the best.” 

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Imagine that setting, up on a hill above a thick strap of trees that follows the snaking river below through an endless ocean of grass. 

“I leave the grave in your care,” Black Elk told those white settlers. “I may never see it again. Care for it for me.”

And so they did. And so they do yet today, 140 years later.

You’ll find Laurel Hill cemetery way atop Neligh, Nebraska; and you’ll find there, just a short hike from the road, a stone that memorializes a Ponca child named White Buffalo Girl.

Won’t be hard to locate. Her grave site is the only one that stays decorated all year long. Just get out of the car and look for a wooden cross, and flowers, lots and lots of flowers. 

Tell you what–go there. Go to Neligh some morning. I don’t care how far you have to drive, just go there, to Laurel Hill cemetery. Go up there and visit the grave of little White Buffalo Girl. It will bless your heart. Call it a pilgrimage, if you will. Better yet, make it one.

Call it a blessing. Because it is. A shelter in the time of storm.

James C. Schaap

James Calvin Schaap is a retired English prof who has been something of a writer for most of the last 40 years. His latest work, a novel, Looking for Dawn, set in reservation country, is the story of two young women joined by their parents' mutual brokenness and, finally, a machine-shed sacrament of reconciliation. He writes and narrates a weekly essay on regional history for KWIT, public radio, Sioux City, Iowa. He and his wife Barbara live on the northern edge of Alton, Iowa, the Sgt. Floyd River a hundred yards or so from their back door. They have a cat--rather, he has them.

6 Comments

  • Daniel J Meeter says:

    Thank you for remembering her. “Remember me, O God.”

  • mstair says:

    “And so they did. And so they do yet today, 140 years later.”

    Begs for part 2; who is “they”; 140 years? Who are the families that keep this going?
    “A pledge to keep have I … “

  • JoAnne Wagner says:

    Preservation, remembrance, next step… restoration. Love AND justice. We still have work to do.

  • David Stravers says:

    Thanks for the remembrance. This is another long sad removal story. One part of remembering that seems to have been lost in the 21st century telling of these stories, is remembering those white citizens who opposed the horrible treatment of the Native American tribes. Many of them were evangelical Christians, missionaries, and people of conscience who tried to make common cause with the anti-slavery movement. They were a small minority, but their views gradually won out, as when the Poncas were eventually declared to be “persons” by the federal courts, and therefore worthy of protection under the constitution.

  • Jan Hoffman says:

    Thank you, Jim Schaap, once again. I’ve seen the statue Dignity above the Missouri. You’ve expanded my horizons, our story.

  • Jim Dekker says:

    Thanks, Jim, for this touching, heart-rending, provocative remembrance. The grave and memorial are now on my list to attend, should I ever get west of the Mississippi again.

Leave a Reply